Google
 
11th December 2007

Bloggers Have No Right To Blog

posted in Cultural, Social Commentary, News & Events | | | View blog reactions | Print This Post

Sports Writer aka loud mouth t.v. talking-head, Stephen A. Smith, made this assertion in a recent interview.

It sprung from a question about the news paper industry:

==On if he considers going back to newspapers, or whether it’s a dying industry:

“I don’t believe that. All the newspaper industry has to do is connect itself better with the internet and guess what? People will read the newsaper on the internet, not rely so much on the paper copy and get with the internet age more so than it has. The foundation of the newspaper business… should never die. We shoud do all we can possible to make sure it lives in perpetuity because it’s extremely important with everything. It keeps radio and television on their ps and qs.

Yes, I absolutely agree that’s what newspapers/journalism should be and do.

Mr. myopic continues though:

“And when you look at the internet business, what’s dangerous about it is that people who are clearly unqualified get to disseminate their piece to the masses. I respect the journalism industry, and the fact of the matter is …someone with no training should not be allowed to have any kind of format whatsoever to disseminate to the masses to the level which they can. They are not trained. Not experts. More important are the level of ethics and integrity that comes along with the quote-unqoute profession hasn’t been firmly established and entrenched in the minds of those who’ve been given that license.

“Therefore, there’s a total disregard, a level of wrecklessness that ends up being a domino effect. And the people who suffer are the common viewers out there and, more importantly, those in the industry who haven’t been fortunate to get a radio or television deal and only rely on the written word. And now they’ve been sabotaged. Not because of me. Or like me. But because of the industry or the world has allowed the average joe to resemble a professional without any credentials whatsoever.”

Is this dude serious? The professionalism in the newspaper industry? If most of the people at most papers are trained, I can’t tell. If they paid for their training they should demand a refund.

Me asking if he’s serious is rhetorical. If I didn’t know Stephen A. I might think he was joking; but unfortunately this is his typical ass-hatery!

This type of self righteousness, eltist attitude, desire to control and limit information, and the scandolousness of the media is the reason Why America Hates the Press; and the way the trained professionals have shown themselves to be nothing more than corporate shills taking pay offs to twist or invent news.

People like Stephen A. and others in the main stream media are just up set because the bloggers, in whole, can’t be bought. Sure, individuals could be, but for every one blogger corperate America (or politicians ) goes and buys, there are a couple of dozen other bloggers checking that bought blogger; and they have the same, or at least the possibility of the same reach.

It means Stephen A. and his main stream cronnies are more and more losing their strangle hold on the dissimenation of information, and hence their ability to get paid, and losing some of their sense of self-appointed importance. Hell, we’re even taking their spots on television news talk shows to discuss issues a lot the time, and I’m sure they hate that. Professional, trained “writers” like Stephen A. Smith love nothing more than an opportunity to get in front of a camera.

He’s right though, we’re not trained:

1. We’re not trained to lie
2. We’re not trained corporate puppets compromising our reporting for big business’ profit agenda
3. We’re not trained to repeat the same handful of stories all day long to the exclusion of all else
4. We’re not trained to be the white house’s mouth piece in the false and fabricated drumbeat to war, or to promote its other agendas
5. We’re not trained to shuck all social responsibility for a dollar
6. We’re not trained to fudge our sources and fabricate stories
7. We’re not trained to ignore stories that are important to minority segments of our society and not just report those that the majority particularly relate to
8. We’re not trained to be lazy, so lazy that many mainstream publications don’t even bother to date their online articles much less do a decent job of reporting
9. We’re not trained to ignore missing people because of their race, looks, and socio-economic background
10. We’re not trained to put gimmick antics, on air personality, and looks of the report before news
11. We’re not trained to bump missing person’s stories for Paris Hilton stories
12. We’re not trained to design our reporting of the news around what will offend or benefit our sponsors
13. We’re not trained to be mistrusted by the majority of the public; making it necessary for the public to develop it’s own direct media
14. In short, we haven’t been trained in how to be shameless corporate shills

Popularity: 23% [?]

Bookmark this story so others can enjoy it:

Related Posts:

There are currently 13 responses to “Bloggers Have No Right To Blog”

Why not let us know what you think by adding your own comment! Your opinion is as valid as anyone elses, so come on... let us know what you think.

  1. 1 On December 11th, 2007, Mes Deux Cents said:

    Hi,

    “Therefore, there’s a total disregard, a level of wrecklessness that ends up being a domino effect. And the people who suffer are the common viewers out there and, more importantly, those in the industry who haven’t been fortunate to get a radio or television deal and only rely on the written word. And now they’ve been sabotaged. Not because of me. Or like me. But because of the industry or the world has allowed the average joe to resemble a professional without any credentials whatsoever.”

    Wow, Stephen A could have been talking about Fox News. Are you sure he wasn’t? (lol)

  2. 2 On December 11th, 2007, D. Yobachi Boswell said:

    Not just Fox, CNN, CBS, and all the rest of them. Go to my blog search box at the top of the page or on the right panel and look up the reports I did on CNN’s Sanjay Gupta’s reporting on Michael Moore’s Sicko. He claimed Moore fudged facts; when Moore gave Gupta the sources he used ahead of time. All of his sources were the UN, the World Health Organization, and the U.S. government; and he demonstrated that his film quoted those sources accurately.

    Also search Buying The War about how almost the entire media apparatus was complicit in drumming up the Iraq war, or at least being silent about obvious holes in the presidents case for war.

  3. 3 On December 11th, 2007, Natalie said:

    If people weren’t allowed to have an expresses opinions to the masses that weren’t in typical roles that have always done so nothing would have ever changed in the world. What an odd premise.

  4. 4 On December 11th, 2007, MrsGrapevine said:

    You said it best, if the only news that claim to have integrity is Fox News, then it’s time for me to turn to the blogs. Honestly, after Peter Jennings death I don’t have the same respect for news or news anchor. Fox News is so out of control, I just want to shut them down for spreading all the -isms. The only news I watch now is ABC World News with Charles Gibson because he’s just the last of a dying breed of reporters who care about people and information more so that he does controversy or fame.

  5. 5 On December 12th, 2007, D. Yobachi Boswell said:

    I think Charlie Gibson is generally a good and trustworthy journalist; but he’s still apart the corporate news apparatus. It’s not that all the individuals involved in main stream news are bad, though a lot of them are; it’s that the whole apparatus is corrupt and about corporate profit and rich people’s perspective - and most of it is very Caucasoid-centric.

    I don’t remember Charlie Gibson standing up and calling the Bush administration out on it’s b.s. drumbeat to war. He sat back and just waved the flag like the rest of the corporate news casters.

    Everybody should check this out: www.blackperspective.net/index.php/buying-the-war/ and watch Buying the War, which you can view for free online.

  6. 6 On December 12th, 2007, D. Yobachi Boswell said:

    That’s so true Natalie. Having either opinion or information left just to the powers that be is retarded adn dangerous; and only serves to maintain the status quo at the expense of the masses.

    And as one person pointed out in the link where I got the quotes from, its inconstitutional to disallow people to express their opinions. What follishness to say that you need credetials to do so. How does getting a piece of paper from a school make you competent or ethical anywhere. For one, you might have cheated and lied your way through school to get the piece of paper.

  7. 7 On December 12th, 2007, cooper said:

    Fox news is an admitted shill so we don’t have to go there, the elitist attitude extends not only to the people writing, some of whom are admittedly pretty stupid even you will admit that Yobachi, but to the fact that Mr.Smith seems to think that people who read other sources of information are too stupid to think for themselves while reading various opinions and taking in several sources of information.

    Mr Smith, and those like him, have to be the ones to tell it like it is or as they see it to be, interpret the truth for the people ….because the people are too stupid to look at information and interpret it without the guidance of a trained journalist.

    That is almost funny.

    People do continue to get their news from standard news sources, most say they will continue to do so but they will do it online. The smart news sources will all go that way in the future. The smart news sources are also looking to see what else is out there. Maybe they can find someone to replace Mr Smith’s archaic attitude.

  8. 8 On December 12th, 2007, LennieG said:

    He totally missed the boat with that loud mouth, ignorant comment. America is STILL free with a FREEDOM OF SPEECH & FREE PRESS.

    End of story.

    Lynn

  9. 9 On December 12th, 2007, Barbara J. Spraggins said:

    Even an idiot can express an opinion. To suggest that people cannot interpret the news and what’s going on in the world without bigoted and bias explanation is ridiculous. I have a problem with the media because what the media is presenting to the public is not true journalism. Their stories are spewed with opinions, untruths and the thoughts of the White majority. The news media is not representative to people of color. When we view the news, we will most certainly see Black and Brown people committing crimes. This is to further perpetuate the myth that people of color are heathens. Very seldom will you see stories which portray us in a good way.

    Yobachi, if not for people such as yourself and others from whom I receive information, there would be no mention of anything happening in the Black community, because we are just not newsworthy, unless some of us are committing crimes. While you kept the stories out there about our missing young Black women, as you mentioned, we had to see hour upon hour focused on Paris Hilton. Like who really gave a damn. Believe it or not, there was a time when even Blacks committing crimes and/or dying was not newsworthy. Blacks only made the news when crimes were committed against Whites.
    Then nine times out of ten, that Black would be dead, so we never got to hear his side of the story, only what the White Media portrayed.

    I know that there is a series on TV right now dispicting the Black American Gangster. They portrayed a gang in Philadelphia, PA., which is my hometown. They stated this gang The Black Mafia, I believe were a faction of the Nation of Islam, called the Fruit of Islam. There was a faction of the muslim faith called the Fruit of Islam which consisted of yonger men. However, first of all, this supposed gang was operating while I was growing up and living in Philly. I had never heard of them. Philly was full of gangs. Most people who lived there knew the gangs by name and what parts of town they came from. I have consulted with a lot of friends and family about this supposed gang and surprise, no one has ever heard of them. They reportedly killed five people, which included children.

    If anyone knows about the Nation of Islam, one thing you should note, if you saw this dispiction of this so-called gang, these men did not even fit the image of a Muslim man. Nation of Islam ministers were clean cut, haads closely shaven and did not present themselves to appear as pimps. What I do remember is the our then facist, racist police chief, Frank Rizzo, tried to destoy the Nation of Islam sect because they were trying to stop gang violence and promoting self-worth and support within the Black community. This was the type of thing that was happening in the Philly that I grew up in. Rizzo was the cause of the destruction of the Black Panther Party. A lot of Blacks may allude to the fact that the Panther party encouraged Blacks to arm themselves and they did so openly.

    However, what most of America did not know, is that the police did not come into the Black neighborhoods to protect and serve, they came to kill. So many innocent Blacks died at the hands of the police, who in turn planted evidence and blamed a lot of deaths on rival gang members. Of course, none of these things ever made the news. There is a brother, Mumia Abu-Jamal,a former Black Panther; from the age of 14, in Philly, whom has been sitting on death row since 1981 for murdering a White cop. The significance of this? There were several witnesses who stated that the police killed one of their own so that they could blame the killing on the Black Panthers. This gave the police the ammunition to raid, kill, jail and literally destroy the Panther Party in Philly. Can we believe this? If this man truely killed a White cop during those times, do you really think they would still have him sitting on death row some almost 30 years later? The brother is broadcasting a radio show from death row.

    I know I may usually long winded, however; my passion are my Black people and the continued injustices we have to suffer. I have stated all of the above to say this. We cannot rely on the White controlled media to report the truth and facts surrounding our communities. We should be encouraging our younger people such as yourself to consider journalism. We need equal representation. We need the truth reported, good or bad.

    I leave you with these words:

    The greatest enemy of truth very often is not the lie, deliberate, contrived and dishonest, but the myth, persistent, persuasive and unrealistic.

    John F. Kennedy

  10. 10 On December 12th, 2007, MrsGrapevine said:

    Yobachi we will have to agree to disagree, Charles Gibson did not have to stand-up because Peter Jennings, lead anchor at the time did. Do you not remember the controversy over reading the names of dead soldiers at the ends of each program. The Bush administration fought it hard, but Peter Jennings and ABC wouldn’t back down, and now to this day their is a tribute to all fallen soldiers at the end of each program. I thinks that’s quite honorable.

    I don’t think they are perfect, nothing mass produce is, but I do believe Charles Gibson and ABC maintain a sense of integrity which is missing in other mass-media productions.

  11. 11 On December 12th, 2007, D. Yobachi Boswell said:

    MrsGrapeVine, dead soldiers? How can you have dead soldiers before a war? Unless you’re talking about the soldiers in the Afghan war, but I only remember this happening after the Iraq war death toll mounted.

    ABC news did not challenge the drumbeat to war, they were apart of it. Again, I’d suggest watching Buying the War. If ABC news is a little bit better than the others, being the lesser bad of the terrible is not commendable.

  12. 12 On December 12th, 2007, invisiblewoman said:

    I was just talking about this for Purple Zoe’s mag–how wonderful it is in the black blogosphere to get REAL news with NO spin or agenda.

    All of the reasons you listed are why I absolutely refuse to watch commercial news.

  13. 13 On December 13th, 2007, OG said:

    Smith,Juan Williams,brothers who get paid to be Little other Brothers and make a darn good livivg doinq it.

Leave a Reply

  • Blogroll

  • Other

    • SiteMeter