BlackPerspective.net
Discussing the Diaspora as seen through an internal Black lens
Hypocritical Plagiarizing by Hillary Clinton: Change You Can Xerox Indeed
February 22nd, 2008
If you’re going to run a campaign making fake claims of plagiarism, you had better not be engaged in doing the exact same thing your making accusations about!
In this NPR roundtable I talk about why Clinton’s claim of Obama plagiarism is false.
Moving beyond that, what’s really so unbelieviable about it, other than it being so petty, is that Hillary routinely as a matter of course does the same thing. And even worse, she lifts stuff from Obama himself! And he didn’t give her permission.
For one, she routinely repeats Bill Clinton rhetoric from days gone by. Here’s one example:
Hillary Last Night: “You know, the hits I’ve taken in life are nothing compared to what goes on every single day in the lives of people across our country.”
Bill In ‘92: “The hits that I took in this election are nothing compared to the hits the people of this state and this country have been taking for a long time”, according to CNN
An article at Democratic Undergroud shows these lifts of repitious phrasology by Clinton, that is identical to the type of usage that she says is plagiarizing for Obama:
-
Here’s a major problem for Senator Clinton’s campaign if her staff and surrogates really want to engage in this so-called “plagiarism” debate. At the Jefferson-Jackson Dinner, Senator Clinton employed what’s called “anaphora” — a common technique of repeating a word or phrase for emphasis in a speech:
I see an America where we stand up to the oil companies…
I see an America where where we say that 47 million people uninsured…
I see an America where where we have schools worthy…
I see an America where where college is affordable again…
And so forth. It was a seriously awesome section of her Jefferson-Jackson speech. It’s a shame that (again, as long as the gloves are off and there has to be this ridiculous “plagiarism” debate) she lifted the “I see an America” anaphora from other politicians, including then-Governor Jimmy Carter. June, 1976:
I see an America poised not only at the brink of a new century, but at the dawn of a new era of honest, compassionate, responsive government.
I see an America with a tax system that does not steal from the poor and give to the rich.
I see an America a job for every man and woman who can work, and a decent standard of living for those who cannot.
I see an America in which my child and your child and every child receives an education second to none in the world.
I see an America in which Martin Luther King’s dream is our national dream.
I see an America on the move again, united, its wounds healed, its head high, a diverse and vital nation, moving into its third century with confidence and competence and compassion, an America that lives up to the majesty of its Constitution and the simple decency of its people.
I also discovered that the “I see an America” line has been used by Congressman Kucinich:
I see an America where equal access and equal rights are obtained by all
And John Edwards with the “I see and America” anaphora:
I see an America where last year the CEO of one of the largest health insurance companies in America made hundreds of millions of dollars in one year. I see an America where ExxonMobil’s profits were $40 billion just a couple of years ago. Record amounts, record profits.
Hell, a Republican running for Congress in the New York 20th named John Wallace used the “I see an America” anaphora (pdf file — there’s a whole page of it, but Wallace is not worth quoting here).
Is “Yes We Will” any different than “Yes We Can”?
How about forgetting a one word difference, Hillary Clinton used “Yes We Can” as a campaign slogan ONE DAY AFTER accusing Obama of plagiarism:
It’s her stance that using even a phrase that someone else used is plagiarism; so she’s not just a plagiarizer, she’s an utterly hypocritical plagiarizer.
Can we steal somebody else’s campaign slogan, Hillary Clinton says, Yes We Can!
Popularity: 7% [?]
posted in Politics, youtube | | | View blog reactions | Print This Post
Related Posts:
12 Responses to “Hypocritical Plagiarizing by Hillary Clinton: Change You Can Xerox Indeed”
Leave a Reply
About The Blog
Yobachi Boswell is creator and publisher of BlackPerspecitve.net. I’m a writer, activist and political watcher based in Nashville, Tennessee. I’ve also been know to do some spoken word and MCing in my day.
I created this site to give new voice to socio-political issues that are in need of thoughtful consideration and redress.
Click the "More About The Blog" link for rest of this statement.
Also, if you like what you see, subscribe for a once a day email to be sent on days when we post; by entering your email address in the feed burner subscription box below.
- More About The Blog...
Subscribe via email
Buy Obama
Blogroll
Site Meter
Meta
Subscribe Via RSS
Recent Posts
- Susan Rice Becomes Second Black Ambassador To The United Nations
- World AIDS Day - Prevention Through Knowledge
- Remembering Sojourner Truth
- More 2008 TV Cancellations Led By Mad TV
- Might Bone Marrow Transplant Be The Cure For AIDS
- Texas and North Carolina Grapple A New With Death Penalty Moratoriums
- Citigroup Getting A Piece of the Bailout
- How the public relations industry sold the Gulf War to the US
- ‘Barack & Curtis’: Short Film Juxtaposing Obama To 50 Cent
- Ignorant Black Bitches, and Heartless Black Studs
Podcast
Podcast Commenting
Taser Abuse Awareness
test
I been watching the news and they have showed at least three moments where she has stolen words from John Edwards, including the end of her speech at the debate Thursday night.
They also showed where she has lifted parts of Obama’s speech as well. Changing the word “a” to “the” doesn’t make the speech your own.
She is a piece of work, I tell ya…
Ha ha, MarvalusOne, that’s about the nicest thing you can say about her; a piece of work
MrsGrapevine, the type of change we can believe in is changing from the Bush and Clinton Dynasties to something new.
Yeah, I don’t know how she accused him of plagiarizing with a straight face…..well I guess botox might help with that.
The Clintons are unscrupulous.
It was pretty ironci to read post debate all the lines she borrowed from other’s, her husband included.
I am happy though. For as much as I am not sure what is going to happen I am proud of the American people….maybe but not necessarily for the first time…;).
It is obvious the people no longer want the pundits to call the shots, they know about the spin rooms now, they don’t want petty arguments and they are not falling for the slams on either side, they don’t want the drama, they have had enough of it they want real answers, debate with no histrionics. This is what has the Clinton campaign and maybe all campaigns a little surprised, it isn’t as easy to fool people any more. Maybe the internet has something to do with that, maybe not, but either way this works in Obama’s favor as he has not been playing the game as long as they have and it is nowhere near as much of a shock to him so his campaign does not have to readjust.
This is another reason why Hillary Rodham Clinton should not be president of the United States. How many more unsecrupulous acts must we be subjected to by her campaign? Her only option seems to be petty attacks against Barack Obama.
Cooper, Hillary came into this campaign fully planning to use the type of hard ball “bash your opponents head in” that shes always known; and she doesn’t know how to adjust and opperate any other way.
All she knows is status quo politican, and she’d be a status quo president.
Vanessa, she’s hurt by the rejection of the electorate and she’s desperate, and hurt people tend to lash out at others. These are the final acts of a desperate woman.
she is swinging in the wind now